Friday, February 23, 2007
man of many names, but the motives stay the same:
Someone has to remind Hossein Derakhshan, the father of Iranian blogging, that he's not supposed to hate freedom. Today in Comment Is Free, the man behind Hoder contends that the U.S. is predisposed to attack any Iranian regime:

Increasingly, a lot of secular Iranians, like myself, are figuring that even if Iran is turned into the most democratic, secular, fair and peaceful state on earth, there is no guarantee the US won't find another excuse to try to overtrow its goverment. It will start bullying Iran for its "devastating role" in climate change, or animal rights, or - who knows? - for obesity.

The interests of the Islamic Republic, with all its internal struggles, challenges and flaws, have never overlapped more closely the interests of Persia as a historic nation. And here lies the surprising support of most Iranians, despite their serious dissatisfaction and frustration, for the Islamic Republic and its resistence towards the US, symbolised by its nuclear programme.

Surely this is overheated. The U.S. never attacked the Shah, so c'mon, Hoder! Iranians have a broad array of political options to choose from, ranging from pliability to outright clientism.

To be serious, Derakhshan's piece is fascinating barometrically. Not even the most fervently secular opponents of the clerical regime have any desire to extend to the United States the benefit of the doubt when it comes to a confrontation with Iran. It shouldn't take a National Intelligence Estimate to understand that Iranians will identify with Ahmadinejad when the Carl Vinson unleashes its fighter pilots. By contrast, notes Abbas Milani, the prospect of a U.N.-enforced sanctions regime creates an actual, behavior-modifying fear within Tehran.
--Spencer Ackerman
Surely this is overheated. The U.S. never attacked the Shah, so c'mon, Hoder! Iranians have a broad array of political options to choose from, ranging from pliability to outright clientism.

Nice.
Blogger James F. Elliott | 12:48 PM